“What is the Brethren Church?” “What do the Brethren believe?” I hear these, and similar questions often from people either new to our church or who have never been to our church. The name “Brethren” isn’t one many people know. We haven’t been around as long as the Catholics, we don’t have as many churches as the Methodists or the Baptists, and we aren’t as culturally distinct as the Amish. And, honestly, we aren’t very big. Our branch of the Brethren family tree boasts only about 100 congregations, scattered mostly through the Great Lakes and the Southeast.
However, those are important questions, and even if we think we know the answers to them, it’s good to be reminded from time to time about what makes our denomination unique among the dozens of denominations that exist in the American church. Our story is worth telling, and the values that are central to our faith have an important role to play in the 21st Century church.
The Brethren Church’s story began in Schwarzenau, Germany in the early 1700s. Though the Protestant Reformation had succeeded in bringing much needed reform to the practice of the Christian faith, there was a sense among many Protestants that the three prominent Churches of the area still weren’t practicing the simple model of faith lived out by the early church in the book of Acts. A man named Alexander Mack, after studying the Scriptures and consulting with others advocating for church reform, came to the conclusion that a new church needed to be started.
Mack and his followers were influenced by two groups of believers who lived in that area of Germany. The Anabaptists, a group that had existed for more than a century, taught that the infant baptism common to all established churches at the time, was not the baptism prescribed by Jesus and the early church in Scripture. Real believers, they thought, needed to be baptized only after making a conscious choice to follow Jesus. The Anabaptists underwent a second baptism, as adults, risking death by doing so, as to reject one’s own infant baptism was at the time considered rebellion against the Church and the king. Besides the emphasis on adult baptism, the Anabaptists also stressed the importance of living in Christian community, with believers holding each other accountable to the commands of Christ and caring for each other’s needs.
The other group that influenced the first Brethren were known as the Radical Pietists. The Pietists stressed “radical” obedience to the Scriptures, focusing not just on believing the right things, but practicing them in their day to day lives. The Pietists believed one must study the Scriptures and be transformed by them through the Holy Spirit. This idea was indeed “radical”, as the method of discipleship used by the Catholic, Lutheran, and Reformed Churches was simply to be instructed by the local priests- personal Bible study was discouraged and even suspect. The Radical Pietists believed that since all Christians had the Holy Spirit, the Spirit would teach them how to live out Christ’s commandments day to day.
Mack’s interpretation of the Church was a blend of both of these approaches: an emphasis on rebaptism and accountable fellowship borrowed from the Anabaptists, as well as strict obedience to the New Testament and worship through the Holy Spirit as practiced by the Radical Pietists.
Convinced they were beginning a new way of doing church, Mack and seven others entered the Eder River in August of 1708 and were baptized, marking the start of the Brethren Church. After experiencing a fair amount of persecution in Germany, the Brethren migrated first to Holland, and then settled in Germantown, Pennsylvania in 1729. In America the church grew and eventually spread to the south and west.
On October 18th we will begin a new sermon series called “The Brethren Message”, where we will examine some of the unique aspects of our story and heritage. We will learn our “origin story”, where we came from and how it shaped our approach to church. We will examine how the Brethren have interpreted the Word of God, the reality of man’s sinfulness, and the salvation available to us through Christ. We will learn how the Brethren define the church and its mission in the world. And we’ll go over the particular way we practice ordinances such as Communion and Baptism.
Through this sermon series, I hope to help each of us to not only understand the Brethren story, but also to embrace it as our own. Whether you were raised Brethren or you’re new to our flavor of church, I think you’ll see from this sermon series that the Brethren approach to the Christian faith is refreshing in its practicality, its grounding in the promises of God’s Word, and its commitment to the true fellowship of believers. I can’t wait to tell our story to you all!
In Christ,
Pastor Jeff Estep